Josephine O’Brien DIT, 4th year
Eleven years after 9/11 America is weaker not stronger. Discuss. 6th December 2012. International Political Economy (BUS4005)
Contents Page number
2.2 Consumer Sentiment5
2.3Airline and Insurance industry5
3.1Cost of War6
3.3Annual Federal Budget Deficit7
3.4Balance of Trade8
4.International Relations 8
4.1The United Kingdom 8
4.3The Middle East 9
5.US Politics 10
5.1Presidency Approval Rating 10
5.2Iraqi War 10
5.3PATRIOT Act 11
5.4Conspiracy Theories 12
6.1Sense of Threat 13
6.2Heightened Paranoia 14
6.3Effect of War 14
The purpose of this essay is to discuss the idea that eleven years after 9/11, America is weaker not stronger.
I will analyse this issue from an international political economic perspective. The effects of this event are so vast that using the ideas of any single academic discipline will not suffice. It calls for an interdisciplinary, multidimensional analysis. With this in mind the aspects that I will take into account for my study are microeconomics, macroeconomics, U.S politics, international relations and sociology. I will account how the attacks negatively impacted these areas, thus making America weaker.
On September 8th 2011, President Barack Obama addressed the nation regarding the progress of America since 9/11. He announced:
Our character as a nation has not changed...The past decade has shown America does not give in to fear...our open markets still provide innovators with the chance to create, our citizens are still free to speak their minds, and our souls are still enriched in our churches and temples, our synagogues and mosques...Nothing can break the will of a truly United States of America
While this speech was uplifting and inspirational, I simply do not agree with it. I will now outline my reasoning for taking this opposing stance.
I will begin with the microeconomic weakening of America since 9/11. Microeconomics deals with the supply and demand for goods and services on a small scale, in other words, by individuals and businesses.
2.1 New York
The businesses in the vicinity of the World Trade Centre in Lower Manhattan suffered major losses. According to Davis (2011) “18,000 small businesses were shut down or destroyed”. The closure of such a vast amount of small businesses in a small area has a massive effect on supply to local customers and of course to the owners of these businesses who became out of job and out of pocket. Not only were the initial businesses destroyed but existing businesses “shunned the area [and] hundreds, if not thousands, of residents moved away” (Fox News, 2012). The Gross City Product of New York was estimated to have been reduced by approximately “$27.3 billion over the last 3 months of 2001 and all of 2002” (Makinen, 2002). As Howard Chernik (2006) observed in the National Tax Journal:
Economic losses quickly spread from the immediate site of the attack to key New York City industries, including travel and tourism. Between 75,000 and 100,000 jobs were lost in New York City during the fourth quarter of 2001 as an immediate result of the attack.
2.2 Consumer Sentiment
The Index of Consumer Sentiment (a research study undertaken by the University of Michigan) showed a decrease in the “mood of consumers and their proclivity to buy various large and small goods and services” (Davis, 2011) in September 2011. This was “the biggest one-month decline since October 1990” (CNN, 2001). This illustrates a clear decrease in consumer demand for goods and services.
2.3 Airline and insurance industry
The airline industry suffered greatly from the decrease in demand....
References: Abbas, Q., 2012, October 31. Lady in pink: Interview with Medea Benjamin. [Online] Available at: http://www.pakistaniaat.net/2012/10/31/lady-in-pink-interview-with-medea-benjamin/
Adely, H., 2011, September 9
Amadeo, K., 2012, September. How the 9/11 attacks Still Affect the Economy Today. [Online] Available: http://useconomy.about.com/od/Financial-Crisis/f/911-Attacks-Economic-Impact.htm.
Baudrillard, J., 2002. The Spirit of Terrorism. London: Verso.
Burke, R., 2005. Effects of 9/11 on individuals and organizations: down but not out! Disaster Prevention and Management, 14(5), 630-631.
Bush, G., 2001. “Winning the War on Terror.” White House. 20 September 2001.
Campbell, R. P., Guilfoyle, K. M., & Howe, C. R., 2012. Proving the Details of the 9/11 Terrorist Attacks: The Admissibility of the Kean Commission Findings. Defence Counsel Journal, 79(3), 278-295.
Chernick, H., & Haughwout, A. F., 2006. Tax Policy and the Fiscal Cost of Disasters: NY and 9/11. National Tax Journal, 59(3), 561-577.
Chermak, S., Bailey, F. Y., and Brown, M., 2003. Media Representation of September 11. Westport: Praeger Publishers.
Churchill, W., 1946. “The Sinews of Peace”. Westminster College, Fulton, Missouri. 5 March, 1946.
CNN, 2001, U.S
Davis, M., 2011. The Impact of 9/11 on Business. [Online] Available: http://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0911/the-impact-of-september-11-on-business.aspx#axzz290U1MDEc
Dean, J., 2011, September 9
Dobrian, J., 2012. 11 Years after 9/11 Residential, Commercial Tenants Demand Higher Security. Journal of Property Management, 77(5), 26-31.
Dosomething.org. 2012. 11 Facts about the Mental Health of Our Troops. [Online] Available: http://www.dosomething.org/tipsandtools/11-facts-about-our-troops-and-mental-health-issues
Drummond, K., 2012
Falk, R., 2006, September 13. The Middle East and the World Five Years after 9/11. [Online] Available: http://www.wagingpeace.org/articles/2006/09/13_falk_after911.htm
Fox News, 2012
Friend, C., 2011, September 13. America Is Weaker Since 9/11. [Online] Available: http://www.newsmax.com/Freind/America-9-11-political/2011/09/16/id/411239
Grabianowski, E., 2012
Gray, J., 2003. 'Bush and Blair deceived us about the reasons for going to war, but they deceived themselves about its impact on Iraq '. New Statesman, 132(4649), 19-21
International Risk Management Institute, 2003
Jones, J., 2011, December 22. U.S. Satisfaction in 2011 Ranks as Second Lowest Since 1979. [Online] Available: http://www.gallup.com/poll/151700/Satisfaction-2011-Ranks-Second-Lowest-1979.aspx
Irregular Times, 2011
Kennedy, P., 2012. Did 9/11 Weaken or Strengthen the United States? [Online] Available: http://www.ihavenet.com/World-September-11th-Did-9-11-Weaken-or-Strengthen-the-United-States-PK.html
King, M, L., 1967
Lipinski, D., 2008. “Working for Veterans”. Legislative Update Fall 2008.
Logan, G., 2007. The Effects of 9/11 on the Airline industry. [Online] Available: http://traveltips.usatoday.com/effects-911-airline-industry-63890.html
Los Angeles Times, 2009
Malik, Z., 2012, July 1. We are Muslim, Please. London: William Heinemann.
Makinen, G., 2002, September 27. The Economic Effects of 9/11: A Retrospective Assessment. Report for Congress. The Library of Congress.
Marrapodi, E., 2011. Poll: Many Americans Uncomfortable with Muslims. [Online] Available: http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2011/09/06/poll-many-americans-uncomfortable-with-muslims/
Nostrand, W., 2011, May 23
Powell, B., 2001. How the World Has Changed. Fortune, 144 (13), 127-132.
Public Religion Research Institute, 2011. What it means to be American. [Online] Available: http://publicreligion.org/research/2011/09/what-it-means-to-be-american/
Rieckhoff, P., 2012, June 22
Gallup, 2012. Congress Approval Remains Historically Low, Now 16%. Washington: Gallup.
Stiglitz, J. E., 2011, September 1. The Price of 9/11. [Online] Available: http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/the-price-of-9-11
Swofford, A., 2012, May 20
Tadjbakhsh, S., 2011, September 12. After 9/11: A wasteland of buried reason. [Online] Available: http://0-www.politico.ie.ditlib.dit.ie/world-politics/7879-after-911-a-wasteland-of-buried-reason.html
The Huffington Post, 2012
The Nashville Scene, 2011. The effect of 9/11 on American policy and politics has been a tragedy unto itself. Press Release: 8 September 2011.
Wagner, D., 2003. Terrorism 's Impact on International Relations. [Online] Available: http://www.irmi.com/expert/articles/2003/wagner03.aspx
Data360.org. 2007. U.S Trade Balance. [Online] Available: http://www.data360.org/dsg.aspx?Data_Set_Group_Id=91
Kollerstrom, N., 2009. Terror on the Tube. Middlesex: Foulsham Publishing
Please join StudyMode to read the full document